Circle Y High Horse Trail Saddle Review

ByEquineathon

If you spend hours on the trail, you know the importance of a comfortable, well-balanced saddle. A poor fit can leave you sore, your horse stiff, and both of you dreading the next ride. That’s why many riders turn to the High Horse by Circle Y Trail Saddle lineup. Built with Circle Y’s craftsmanship but priced more accessibly, these saddles balance comfort, durability, and style. In this review, we’ll look at the best High Horse trail saddles available today, compare their features, and help you decide which one is right for you.

Quick Picks: Best Circle Y High Horse Trail Saddles

Buyer’s Guide: How to Choose a High Horse Trail Saddle

Before picking your saddle, here are some important points to keep in mind:

  • Tree Size: Choose Regular, Wide, or Extra Wide depending on your horse’s build.
  • Seat Size: Match to your body type and comfort needs, usually 15”–17”.
  • Weight: Cordura models are lighter; full leather saddles are heavier but more durable.
  • Purpose: Some High Horse models are better for gaited horses, others for endurance, and some for casual trail riding.
  • Hardware: Stainless steel or brass hardware resists rust and lasts longer.
  • Budget: Expect to spend $2,000+ for the higher-end options that last for years.

Detailed Product Reviews

1. High Horse Big Springs Trail Saddle

Who It’s For: Riders who want all-day trail comfort with a traditional western look.

  • Key Benefits: 5” cantle for security, pre-turned fenders, brass hardware, and long saddle strings.
  • Pros: Great back support, multiple tree widths, rugged leather.
  • Cons: Heavier than Cordura models, needs break-in period.

Final Verdict: The Big Springs Trail Saddle is the best overall pick for serious trail riders who demand both comfort and durability. Check latest price here.

2. High Horse El Campo Cordura Trail Saddle

Who It’s For: Riders who want a lighter saddle without losing quality.

  • Key Benefits: Cordura skirts and fenders, leather seat, and lighter weight build.
  • Pros: Easier to lift, affordable compared to full leather saddles.
  • Cons: Less premium feel, not as long-lasting as all-leather.

Final Verdict: Perfect for riders who want High Horse quality at a friendlier price. Check latest price here.

3. High Horse Daisetta Trail Saddle

Who It’s For: Riders who love premium leather saddles with extra detail.

  • Key Benefits: Hand-tooled floral designs, high-quality leather, secure seat.
  • Pros: Beautiful craftsmanship, secure deep seat, excellent fit for wider horses.
  • Cons: Price is on the higher end, heavier to carry.

Final Verdict: If you want a saddle that looks as good as it rides, the Daisetta is a premium investment. Check latest price here.

4. High Horse Willow Springs Trail Saddle

Who It’s For: Riders who prioritize a lightweight build with a stylish look.

  • Key Benefits: Rounded skirt design, Cordura materials, and comfort seat.
  • Pros: Lightweight, easy to handle, great for smaller riders.
  • Cons: Not as rugged as full leather, less padding than premium models.

Final Verdict: A great option if you want lightweight performance with a modern design. Check latest price here.

5. High Horse Lockhart Trail Saddle

Who It’s For: Riders who want a secure, deep seat for challenging trails.

  • Key Benefits: Deep seat, high cantle, and reinforced stirrup leathers.
  • Pros: Secure ride on steep trails, excellent control.
  • Cons: Heavier design, limited color choices.

Final Verdict: Best for riders tackling rough terrain. Check latest price here.

6. High Horse Oakland Trail Saddle

Who It’s For: Riders who need comfort and stability on long rides.

  • Key Benefits: Wide tree options, soft padded seat, durable construction.
  • Pros: Good for wide-backed horses, very comfortable seat.
  • Cons: Bulkier frame, premium pricing.

Final Verdict: The Oakland is an excellent option for riders with wide-backed horses who want lasting comfort. Check latest price here.

Comparison Table

Model Key Features Specs Price
Big Springs 5” cantle, brass hardware, leather build Seat: 15-17” | Weight: ~35 lbs Check Price
El Campo Cordura Lightweight Cordura skirts, leather seat Seat: 15-17” | Weight: ~27 lbs Check Price
Daisetta Hand-tooled leather, deep seat Seat: 15-17” | Weight: ~36 lbs Check Price
Willow Springs Rounded skirt, Cordura build Seat: 15-16” | Weight: ~28 lbs Check Price
Lockhart Deep seat, reinforced stirrup leathers Seat: 15-17” | Weight: ~37 lbs Check Price
Oakland Wide tree options, padded seat Seat: 16-17” | Weight: ~38 lbs Check Price

FAQ

Are High Horse saddles made by Circle Y?

Yes, the High Horse line is built by Circle Y, using the same trees and craftsmanship but designed to be more affordable.

How do I know which tree width my horse needs?

Regular fits narrower-backed horses, Wide fits broader shoulders, and Extra Wide is best for very stocky or gaited horses.

Are Cordura saddles as good as leather?

Cordura saddles are lighter and easier to handle, but full leather saddles typically last longer and hold up better under heavy use.

What’s the average price of a High Horse Trail Saddle?

Expect to pay $2,000–$2,500 for a new High Horse saddle, depending on the model and materials.

Do these saddles come with warranties?

Yes, most come with warranties on the tree and limited warranties on workmanship.

Conclusion

The High Horse Trail Saddles by Circle Y are an excellent investment for anyone who spends serious time on horseback. They balance comfort, durability, and style in a way that few saddles in this price range can. Whether you choose the lightweight El Campo, the premium Daisetta, or the all-around Big Springs, you’ll get a saddle built to last and keep both you and your horse happy on the trail.

Ready to upgrade your ride? Explore the full range of High Horse Trail Saddles here and find the one that fits you and your horse best.