Best Circle Y Western Saddles

ByEquineathon

When it comes to Western saddles, few names are as trusted as Circle Y. Founded in 1960 in Yoakum, Texas, Circle Y has earned a reputation for building saddles that combine craftsmanship, comfort, and durability. Whether you’re working cattle, competing in barrel racing, or enjoying long trail rides, Circle Y has a saddle built to meet your needs. But with so many choices, which models stand out as the best?

Quick Picks – Best Circle Y Saddles

Buyer’s Guide – How to Choose the Right Circle Y Saddle

Before investing in a Circle Y saddle, it’s important to understand the key features and how they affect your riding experience.

  • Tree Type: Rigid trees offer stability for ranch and roping, while Flex2 trees provide adaptability and comfort for trail riding.
  • Seat Size & Style: A deep seat gives security in barrel racing, while flatter seats give more freedom for working ranch riders.
  • Rigging System: Circle Y’s 3-way adjustable in-skirt rigging ensures better balance and fit.
  • Discipline: Choose based on your main use—barrel, ranch, roping, show, or trail.
  • Leather & Finish: Tooling, suede seats, and decorative designs add style but also impact durability and maintenance.
  • Weight: Heavy-duty ranch saddles can be 38–40 lbs, while Flex2 trail saddles are much lighter at ~27–30 lbs.

Detailed Reviews – Best Circle Y Saddles

1. Circle Y 1340 Midland Rancher

Who it’s for: Ranchers and riders who need a tough, dependable working saddle.

  • Built on a DURAhide-covered Precision tree
  • 3-way in-skirt rigging for stability
  • Hand-tooled leather for a classic ranch look

Pros: Rugged, long-lasting, secure seat

Cons: Heavy; not ideal for barrel racing or short casual rides

Final Verdict: A true workhorse for serious riders. Check Price

2. Circle Y Flex2 Trail Saddle

Who it’s for: Trail riders who want comfort over long hours.

  • Flex2 tree adapts to different horse backs
  • Shock-absorbing impact foam seat
  • Lightweight design (~29 lbs)

Pros: Comfortable, versatile, fits many horses

Cons: Not ideal for roping; higher price

Final Verdict: A top choice for trail enthusiasts. See Price

3. Circle Y High Horse Barrel Saddle

Who it’s for: Barrel racers and rodeo riders.

  • Forward-hung stirrups and deep seat for secure turns
  • Lightweight build for speed
  • Affordable compared to premium models

Pros: Budget-friendly, good grip, competition-ready

Cons: Not ideal for long trail rides; less durability

Final Verdict: Great entry-level performance saddle. View Price

4. Circle Y Julie Goodnight Wind River Flex2

Who it’s for: Riders who want premium comfort and professional design.

  • Flex2 tree with tunnel skirt for better horse fit
  • Memory foam seat with ergonomic stirrups
  • Designed with trainer Julie Goodnight

Pros: High comfort, excellent craftsmanship

Cons: Premium price; heavier than ultralight saddles

Final Verdict: A luxury trail saddle that delivers. Check Price

5. Circle Y Martha Josey Ultimate Cash Barrel Saddle

Who it’s for: Barrel racers who want the Josey signature design.

  • Deep seat with high cantle for maximum security
  • Forward-hung stirrups for balance in tight turns
  • Durable DURAhide tree

Pros: Secure seat, designed by a champion, stylish

Cons: Expensive; not versatile beyond competition

Final Verdict: A proven winner in the barrel arena. View Price

6. Circle Y Sheridan Ranch Saddle

Who it’s for: Ranch hands and working riders.

  • Heavy-duty construction for roping and cattle work
  • Rawhide-wrapped horn for strength
  • Classic cowboy aesthetic

Pros: Extremely durable, secure fit

Cons: Heavy; not suited for trail riders

Final Verdict: Built for the toughest jobs. Check Price

Comparison Table

Saddle Best For Key Features Weight Price Link
1340 Midland Rancher Ranch Work DURAhide tree, 3-way rigging ~38 lbs Check Price
Flex2 Trail Trail Riding Flex2 tree, shock-absorbing seat ~29 lbs See Price
High Horse Barrel Barrel Racing Forward-hung stirrups, deep seat ~27 lbs View Price
Julie Goodnight Wind River Premium Trail Flex2 tree, ergonomic stirrups ~32 lbs Check Price
Martha Josey Ultimate Cash Barrel Racing Deep seat, DURAhide tree ~29 lbs View Price
Sheridan Ranch Heavy Ranch Work Rawhide horn, heavy-duty build ~40 lbs Check Price

FAQ – Circle Y Saddles

Are Circle Y saddles worth the price?

Yes. They’re known for durability, comfort, and horse-friendly design. A well-fitted Circle Y can last decades.

What’s the difference between Flex2 and traditional trees?

Flex2 trees offer flexibility and comfort for horses with varying back shapes, while traditional rigid trees provide maximum stability for roping and ranch work.

Do Circle Y saddles require break-in?

Most come with Softee leather, which reduces break-in time compared to older-style saddles.

Which Circle Y is best for beginners?

The High Horse Barrel saddle is affordable, lightweight, and secure—great for riders starting out in performance disciplines.

How do I size a Circle Y saddle?

Most adults use 15–17” seats. Measure your inseam, riding style, and horse’s back before choosing.

Conclusion

Circle Y saddles are among the best investments a Western rider can make. From the tough Midland Rancher to the high-performance Josey barrel models and the luxurious Julie Goodnight Flex2 saddles, Circle Y offers something for every discipline.

If you want the best all-around balance of quality and versatility, go for the Circle Y Midland Rancher. Trail riders will love the Flex2 Trail, while competitors should consider the Martha Josey Ultimate Cash for proven performance.

Click here to check today’s best Circle Y saddles and prices