Best Circle Y Reining Saddles

ByEquineathon

Reining demands precision. Spins, rollbacks, sliding stops, and fast transitions put pressure not only on the rider but also on the saddle. The right saddle keeps you centered, helps you stay secure, and allows your horse to move freely. Circle Y has been building saddles for over 60 years, and their reining models are designed for riders who want durability, style, and performance. In this guide, we’ll look at the best Circle Y reining saddles, key buying tips, full product reviews, and a comparison table to help you choose the right one.

Quick Picks: Best Circle Y Reining Saddles

Buyer’s Guide: What to Look for in a Circle Y Reining Saddle

Before buying, make sure your saddle checks the boxes that matter for reining:

  • Deep Seat with Moderate Cantle: Keeps you secure during slides without locking you in too tight.
  • Forward Skirt & Free Leg Movement: Shorter, forward skirts let you use your legs freely during spins.
  • Low Horn / Moderate Swell: Prevents interference when leaning forward into maneuvers.
  • Rigging Stability: In-skirt or properly placed rigging keeps the saddle balanced and steady under rein pressure.
  • Quality Leather & Tree: Reining maneuvers stress the saddle — strong leather, reinforced tree, and reliable stitching are non-negotiable.
  • Weight Balance: Heavy enough for stability, but not so heavy it slows down your horse’s motion or wears you out.

Detailed Product Reviews

1. Circle Y 2672 Ohio Reiner

Who it’s for: Riders who want a true reining-specific saddle built to handle the discipline’s demands.

  • Key Benefits:
    • Deep, secure seat for sliding stops and spins.
    • Forward skirt design for free leg movement.
    • Balanced rigging keeps saddle stable under pressure.
    • High-quality Circle Y craftsmanship and leather.
  • Pros: Purpose-built for reining, great seat balance, durable, stylish enough for shows.
  • Cons: Higher price point, heavier than all-purpose saddles.

Final Verdict: The best all-around reining saddle in Circle Y’s lineup. Check price here.

2. Circle Y Cutting & Reining Saddle (16")

Who it’s for: Riders who cross between cutting and reining, or who want a versatile reining-capable saddle.

  • Key Benefits:
    • Solid build with reinforced tree.
    • Suitable for both cutting and reining work.
    • More affordable compared to specialized models.
  • Pros: Versatile, strong leather, good seat support, budget-friendly compared to premium Circle Y models.
  • Cons: Less specialized, heavier than some reining-only saddles.

Final Verdict: Great for riders who want a dual-purpose saddle. See current offers.

3. Circle Y Show-Ready Reining Saddle

Who it’s for: Riders who want a reining saddle with show-ring looks, decorative tooling, and premium comfort.

  • Key Benefits:
    • Ornate tooling and premium finish for show presentation.
    • Deep reining seat with free leg movement.
    • Premium Circle Y leather and stitching for longevity.
  • Pros: Eye-catching design, great performance, strong resale value.
  • Cons: Expensive, heavier due to tooling and leather.

Final Verdict: Perfect for competitive riders who want both looks and performance. Shop here.

4. Circle Y Classic Reiner

Who it’s for: Riders looking for a straightforward, functional reining saddle with no extra frills.

  • Key Benefits:
    • Balanced reining seat with secure cantle.
    • Strong leather and hardware for durability.
    • Simpler design keeps weight manageable.
  • Pros: Reliable, durable, practical for training.
  • Cons: Not as decorative, limited availability in some regions.

Final Verdict: A solid training and practice saddle.

5. Circle Y Ranch/Reining Hybrid

Who it’s for: Riders who need a reining-capable saddle that also stands up to occasional ranch or cattle work.

  • Key Benefits:
    • Reinforced tree with working rigging.
    • Comfortable reining seat but with sturdier build.
    • Good for riders who want one saddle for both ranch chores and arena work.
  • Pros: Multi-use, strong, balanced rigging.
  • Cons: Heavier than pure reining saddles, less leg freedom than dedicated models.

Final Verdict: Ideal for riders who mix reining with ranch-style work.

Comparison Table

Model Best For Weight Seat Price
Ohio Reiner 2672 Dedicated reining ~32 lbs 15"–16" Check Price
Cutting & Reining Dual use ~34 lbs 16" View
Show-Ready Reiner Competition & shows ~35 lbs 15"–16" Shop
Classic Reiner Training, daily use ~30 lbs 15" —
Ranch/Reining Hybrid Mixed ranch + arena ~36 lbs 15"–16" —

FAQ

Are Circle Y reining saddles good for beginners?

Yes. The deep seats and secure cantles help new riders stay centered during fast maneuvers. Beginners benefit from saddles like the Ohio Reiner because they’re designed for stability and balance.

Can I use a Circle Y reining saddle for other disciplines?

Yes, many riders use them for trail or general arena work. But keep in mind that reining saddles are built for quick maneuvers, not long-distance trail riding or heavy roping.

What’s the average price of a Circle Y reining saddle?

Most models fall between $2,000 and $2,800 new, depending on leather, tooling, and features.

How heavy are Circle Y reining saddles?

Weights range from 30–36 lbs depending on model and materials. Show saddles with heavy tooling are on the higher end.

Conclusion & Call-to-Action

The best Circle Y reining saddles combine balance, rider security, and quality build. For dedicated reining riders, the Ohio Reiner 2672 is the top choice. If you cross between cutting and reining, the Cutting & Reining Saddle is excellent value. For competitive show riders, the Show-Ready Reiner provides beauty and performance in one package.

Ultimately, fit is king. Make sure your horse’s back shape, tree width, and your own seat size match the saddle. A properly chosen Circle Y reining saddle will help you ride with more confidence, comfort, and style.

Ready to find yours? Explore the top Circle Y reining saddles here: