Best Circle Y 16” Saddles – Reviews & Buyer’s Guide
For many riders, a 16-inch seat is the sweet spot—it’s one of the most popular saddle sizes for adult western riders. Circle Y, one of the most trusted saddle makers in the U.S., offers 16” options across their trail, barrel, ranch, and show lines. Whether you’re looking for lightweight comfort on the trail or a sturdy ranch saddle, Circle Y has a model to fit. Here’s our complete guide to the best Circle Y saddles in 16-inch sizes.
Quick Picks – Best Circle Y Saddles in 16”
- Best Overall: Circle Y Flex2 Trail Saddle (16”) – Lightweight, versatile, and perfect for long rides.
- Best Budget: Circle Y High Horse Daisetta Trail Saddle (16”) – Affordable and lightweight with Cordura/leather mix.
- Best Premium: Circle Y Sheridan Ranch Saddle (16”) – Heavy-duty ranch saddle with premium leather.
Buyer’s Guide – Why Choose a 16” Saddle?
The right seat size makes a huge difference in rider comfort and performance. Here’s why 16” saddles are so popular:
- Standard Adult Size: Fits most average-sized riders comfortably.
- Versatile Use: Available across Circle Y’s trail, ranch, barrel, and show lines.
- Balance of Space & Security: Large enough to be comfortable but not so big that riders slide around.
- Resale Value: 16” saddles are in high demand, so they hold value well.
Detailed Reviews – Best Circle Y Saddles (16” Seat)
1. Circle Y Flex2 Trail Saddle (16”)
Who it’s for: Trail riders who want lightweight comfort for long days in the saddle.
- Flex2 tree with tunnel skirt for horse comfort
- Impact foam seat with Softee leather fenders
- Weighs ~29 lbs
Pros: Comfortable, versatile, quick break-in
Cons: Not for heavy ranch roping
Verdict: The most popular Circle Y trail saddle in 16”. Check Price
2. Circle Y High Horse Daisetta Trail Saddle (16”)
Who it’s for: Riders wanting affordability and light weight.
- Leather/Cordura mix (weighs ~23 lbs)
- Padded suede seat for comfort
- In-skirt rigging for close contact
Pros: Budget-friendly, lightweight, easy to saddle
Cons: Less decorative than premium models
Verdict: A smart buy for budget-conscious trail riders. See Price
3. Circle Y Sheridan Ranch Saddle (16”)
Who it’s for: Ranch riders and ropers who need strength and durability.
- Rawhide-covered wood tree for roping
- Herman Oak leather with hand tooling
- Weighs ~40 lbs
Pros: Strong, stylish, built for work
Cons: Heavy; premium price
Verdict: A top choice for working cowboys. View Price
4. Circle Y Tammy Fischer Treeless Barrel Saddle (16”)
Who it’s for: Barrel racers who want speed, security, and horse freedom.
- Treeless design for flexibility
- Deep suede seat with forward stirrups
- Lightweight (~23 lbs)
Pros: Secure seat, horse-friendly, lightweight
Cons: Not for ranch roping
Verdict: A fantastic 16” barrel racing saddle. See Price
5. Circle Y Equitation Show Saddle (16”)
Who it’s for: Riders focused on horsemanship and equitation in the show ring.
- Equitation seat for correct rider position
- Hand-tooled leather with silver plate trim
- Close contact skirt design
Pros: Balanced, elegant, durable
Cons: Heavier (~36 lbs); higher price
Verdict: A show-ready saddle that impresses in the arena. View Price
Comparison Table – Best Circle Y Saddles (16” Seat)
| Saddle | Best For | Key Features | Weight | Price Link |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Flex2 Trail | Trail Riding | Flex2 tree, impact foam seat | ~29 lbs | Check Price |
| High Horse Daisetta | Budget Trail | Leather/Cordura mix, padded seat | ~23 lbs | See Price |
| Sheridan Ranch | Ranch & Roping | Rawhide tree, premium leather | ~40 lbs | View Price |
| Tammy Fischer Treeless Barrel | Barrel Racing | Treeless design, suede seat | ~23 lbs | See Price |
| Equitation Show | Show & Equitation | Equitation seat, silver trim | ~36 lbs | View Price |
FAQ – Circle Y 16” Saddles
What size rider fits a 16” saddle?
Generally, a 16” seat fits adult riders with a medium to larger build. Riders around 150–200 lbs usually find 16” ideal, though body shape and preference also matter.
Do all Circle Y saddles come in 16”?
Yes, most popular models are offered in 15”, 16”, and 17” sizes, with 16” being the most common.
Are 16” saddles good for resale?
Yes. Since they’re the most common adult size, Circle Y 16” saddles hold resale value better than 14” or 18”.
Are 16” Circle Y saddles heavier?
Not necessarily. The weight depends on the saddle type (trail, ranch, show), not just the seat size.
Conclusion
Circle Y 16-inch saddles are a perfect fit for most adult riders, offering comfort, security, and versatility. The Flex2 Trail is the best overall choice, while the Daisetta Trail offers budget-friendly performance. For heavy ranch work, the Sheridan Ranch Saddle is unbeatable, while barrel racers and show riders will love the Tammy Fischer Treeless and Equitation Show models. No matter your discipline, Circle Y has a 16” saddle that’s built to last.
Click here to check today’s best Circle Y 16” Saddles and prices